Dutasteride vs. Finasteride: Choosing the Best Hair Loss Treatment

Overview

Wondering whether to choose dutasteride or finasteride for hair loss? Both medications can be effective options, but the right choice depends on your specific needs. Dutasteride (brand name: Avodart) and finasteride (brands: Propecia, Proscar) are oral 5-alpha reductase inhibitors used to treat conditions like benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) and hair loss. While dutasteride is FDA-approved solely for BPH, some healthcare providers prescribe it off-label for hair loss. In contrast, finasteride has the FDA’s approval for both BPH and hair loss, supported by extensive clinical evidence. Though they work similarly, key differences exist in their approved uses, dosages, and potential side effects. Keep reading to understand which works better for whom. 

Which is better, dutasteride or finasteride, for hair loss?

When it comes to treating hair loss, finasteride is the FDA-approved option, supported by substantial clinical evidence. In contrast, dutasteride is typically prescribed off-label.

Mechanism of action

• Dutasteride: Inhibits both type I and type II 5-alpha-reductase enzymes.
• Finasteride: Inhibits only the type II enzyme.

Since both isoenzymes are found in hair follicles, it’s reasonable to suggest that dutasteride may be more effective than finasteride in promoting hair regrowth.

Both medications function as DHT blockers. They prevent the conversion of testosterone into dihydrotestosterone (DHT), a hormone that contributes to hair follicle miniaturization and subsequent hair loss. By lowering DHT levels, both drugs can help slow down or even reverse this miniaturization process.

“Both dutasteride and finasteride are proven treatments for hair loss. While both work to block DHT, their effectiveness varies depending on the individual. Consulting with a healthcare professional can help determine which treatment is more suitable for you” Dr. Asim Cheema

Similarities

• Both medications are used to treat male androgenetic alopecia (male pattern baldness).
• They work by reducing DHT levels, which helps manage prostate growth, decreases hair loss, and promotes hair growth.
• Finasteride and dutasteride are similarly priced and are usually covered by most commercial insurance plans.
• Both can be used in combination with topical minoxidil for enhanced hair growth results.

Differences between finasteride and dutasteride

Despite their similarities, there are crucial distinctions:

• Potency: Dutasteride is more potent, blocking more testosterone conversion to DHT.
• FDA approval: Only finasteride is FDA-approved for androgenetic alopecia, while dutasteride is used off-label.

Efficacy evidence

A recent study provides insights into the effectiveness of these treatments:

• A systematic review of three clinical trials involving 576 participants showed that dutasteride yielded significantly better results than finasteride, particularly regarding total hair count and visual assessments.
• A meta-analysis of data from 30 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) also identified dutasteride as a more effective treatment for male androgenetic alopecia (AGA).
• In a post-marketing surveillance study conducted in Japan, patients on dutasteride showed notable improvements in hair count over a 52-week period.

In short, the findings from various studies highlight the effectiveness and safety of dutasteride compared to finasteride for treating male pattern baldness. With its higher efficacy and manageable side effects, dutasteride is increasingly recommended for clinical use, particularly in regions like South Korea and Japan, where both medications are considered first-line treatments for male androgenetic alopecia (AGA).

Should I switch from finasteride to dutasteride?

Deciding whether to switch from finasteride to dutasteride is important for many patients. The following might help you address your concerns: 

Reasons to consider switching

• Potency: Dutasteride is a more potent 5-alpha reductase (5AR) inhibitor than finasteride. This means it may offer better results in reducing DHT levels and improving symptoms related to BPH or hair loss.

• Side Effects: Research indicates that switching to dutasteride does not necessarily lead to more significant side effects than those experienced with finasteride.

Doctors suggest that rather than alternating between the two medications, replacing finasteride with dutasteride on a daily basis may be more beneficial. This approach can provide the advantages of dutasteride’s potency while minimizing potential side effects. However, some people might experience this while using dutasteride. Therefore, it is best to consult a doctor before switching to another medication. 

Dosage Comparison

Understanding the appropriate dosages for dutasteride and finasteride is essential for effective treatment. Here’s a comparison of their dosage forms, strengths, and recommended dosing:

Dutasteride

• Dosage form: Available as an oral capsule.
• Strength: Comes in a strength of 0.5 mg.
• Recommended dosage for male pattern hair loss: There is no FDA-approved dosage for this indication.

Finasteride

• Dosage form: Available as an oral tablet.
• Strengths: Offered in 1 mg and 5 mg strengths.
• Recommended dosage for male pattern hair loss: The typical dosage is 1 mg once daily.

Your healthcare provider may recommend a different dosage based on your specific needs, so follow their instructions for optimal results.

What are the cons of dutasteride?

While dutasteride can be effective for treating conditions like BPH and hair loss, it is important to be aware of its potential drawbacks:

Allergic reactions

Dutasteride may cause serious allergic reactions in some individuals. Symptoms to watch for include:

• Rash
• Itching
• Swelling (especially of the face, tongue, or throat)
• Difficulty breathing

If you experience these symptoms, you must stop taking dutasteride immediately and seek medical help.

Risk of prostate cancer

Although rare, there is evidence suggesting that dutasteride may increase the risk of a serious form of prostate cancer that can spread quickly. It’s essential to discuss this risk with your healthcare provider, especially if you have a history of prostate issues.

Why is dutasteride not FDA-approved?

Dutasteride has not received FDA approval for treating hair loss due to insufficient clinical studies demonstrating its efficacy for this specific use. While the medication has shown promise in preliminary studies, the following points clarify its current status:

• Lack of sufficient evidence: The existing studies on dutasteride’s effectiveness for hair loss are not robust enough to meet the FDA’s stringent approval criteria.

• FDA approval for BPH: Dutasteride is FDA-approved for the treatment of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), where it has been proven to be safe and effective.

While some healthcare providers may prescribe dutasteride off-label for hair loss, it’s important to be aware that its use for this purpose lacks formal FDA endorsement.

When to consult a doctor?

If you are considering finasteride or dutasteride for treating conditions such as BPH or hair loss, it’s essential to consult a healthcare provider. Here are some important points to consider:

• Similar mechanism: Both finasteride and dutasteride work to reduce prostate size by blocking the conversion of testosterone to DHT, making them similarly effective for alleviating BPH-related urinary problems.

• Hair loss treatment: While both medications may be used for hair loss in men, finasteride is more commonly prescribed and has more substantial clinical evidence supporting its effectiveness for this purpose.

• Potential side effects: Both drugs can cause sexual side effects, with some studies suggesting that dutasteride might carry a slightly higher risk.

• Professional guidance: It’s crucial to speak with your healthcare provider to discuss your symptoms, medical history, and whether one of these medications could benefit you.

You can make a more informed decision regarding your treatment options by consulting with a healthcare professional.

FAQs about dutasteride vs finasteride